A case for minimum guaranteed income, with responsibility on people

by Jun 26, 2020Thinking outside the bottle0 comments

universal basic incomeuniversal basic income

Paulo Pinto

Alti Wine Exchange founding member

Greetings, dear reader,

If you have been reading my latest posts on issues that range from global markets and trends in economy and finances to fine wine investment, you know I have been suggesting the need for a new type of Central Bank: one that has the people at the core. I call it the Central Bank of Social Security.

Well, I am back again, and this time with some debate on a recurring theme in my recent articles on the issue: the debate on minimum guaranteed income.

One of the comments we have received from my recent text on Central Banks of Social Security was: “This is just a way of keeping people poor and dependent on the government”. Another comment we received was: “This is a sure way for governments to go broke.”

Let’s start with the second comment.

The reason to create a Central Bank of Social Security is exactly for the government not to go broke. What happens now in countries with their own Central Bank is: governments make promises, then they have to borrow money, then their debt increases, then the Central Bank prints money.

What happens after as a result is, that local currency devalues, people start to blame the rich, then more money flows out of the country and then Central Bank needs to print more money. This sequence, when out of control, results in situations like Argentina, or Venezuela or Zimbabwe.

* * *

As debt increases it restrict economic growth, it is also the catalyst for more taxes, because a fiscally challenged government never makes itself smaller, increasing taxation instead.

At this point, savers are under attack and the purchasing power of the currency is diminishing, with public faith in it eroding – driving people to park money in a different currency or gold for safety and fear of more currency depreciation.


With a Central Bank of Social Security, this dogma changes and we need to accept a new one:

All individuals over 18 will receive minimum guaranteed income tax free, and this will replace all other subsidies in existence.

Minimum guaranteed income is cumulative with salaries, and it’s up to people to save it or to spend it.

This is not a system to make us all equal, because we are not. There is only one Messi, one CR7, one Michael Jordan, and many other different players with different skills and different levels of professionalism.

What this Central Bank of Social Security will allow is for people to have a minimum level of dignity and a tool to shine in life with their own skills, and be happy with themselves or not.

This will allow to put back the responsibility on people and out of the government. If people decide to live on the minimum guaranteed income it’s their choice, but they cannot have claims on failed promises from government.

Life is made of individual choices, and a Central Bank of Social Security will reinforce those choices.

‘Paying to generate unemployment?’

I can hear you already saying, “Pay people not to work… and you’ll get people not working”.

This, of course, it’s one way of seeing it and there are probably people willing to do just that, but the goal is providing them the tools with dignity to do whatever they want – to bring added value to society, or to be part of the ‘’useless class’’.

If they want to study to improve further skills, they can – and, like that, guarantee later jobs that pay more. In no circumstances they have to feel unemployed or out of the market. If they want to work and put the money of the minimum guaranteed income into an investment account, they can: it’s only their choice.

This will answer the first question. It will be people individually deciding if they want to be poor or rich if they want to be consumers or producers. It’s a system that will allow anyone to be really good at what they want – or spend a lifetime trying.

Featured articles on wine and finances

Summer is coming – and things really do not look promising


Investing in fine wine remotely in times of Covid, tariffs and stuck cargo ships


Outside the bottle | Building wealth wisely, change is both need and opportunity


Alti Wine Exchange Indexes in 2020: despite it all, safe and strong returns for fine wine


Outside the bottle | A scale for reasoning and a crisis warning


Outside the bottle | A digital euro is coming. We should be worried


Outside the bottle | Prosperity is not automatic: a lesson from top wine producers


Fine wine withstood a tough year. What's ahead for 2021?


Outside the bottle | A Great Reset to save democracy: rebooting the financial system


Outside the bottle | Reseting the monetary regime to achieve true freedom


The other comment is much easier to address.

This minimum guaranteed income will not be a cost to the government, so it can’t go broke because of it. Obviously, there is no bad situation that governments cannot make worst. But they will need to do it managing government – not people, as they do now.

What does it mean? It means governments will have no incentive to redistribute wealth because a minimum income is guaranteed, but it is not their responsibility.

It means governments will need only to allocate money raised in taxes in a way that will help the country be competitive. Taxes will pay for the services the government provides, and it is in their interest to free the economy.

Having said that, I believe taxes have a moral role. There should be a maximum of income allowed to anyone, to prevent money to gain power.

Money should be a tool accessible to those able to create wealth, and – as we know – not many people are able to create wealth.

* * *

That is all for today. I hope to have eased such concerns raised by some of our readers.

Any feedbacks and other comments you would like to have from us? Just let me know and I will be happy to address it soon.

Until next time.


More articles by Paulo Pinto


Summer is coming – and things really do not look promising

Building a sound strategy for your resources in the face of inflation and worsening living standards has become more crucial than ever

Outside the bottle | Building wealth wisely, change is both need and opportunity

Away from falsely reassuring economic news, seeking alternative financial strategies is inevitable in the face of low interest rates and looming inflation

Outside the bottle | A scale for reasoning and a crisis warning

It takes personal trust to let the next generation run its own course in a world where everything and everyone are being homogenized

Outside the bottle | Luxury is far simpler than what we once thought it was

The pandemic shows that small things that were once taken for granted can simply vanish, in both our economic and social lives

Outside the bottle | On miscommunication and generational mismatches


Outside the bottle | A digital euro is coming. We should be worried


Outside the bottle | Prosperity is not automatic: a lesson from top wine producers


Outside the bottle | A Great Reset to save democracy: rebooting the financial system


Outside the bottle | Reseting the monetary regime to achieve true freedom


Outside the bottle | Why we need a Great Reset of the financial system


Explore More from Our Blog

Would you bring your child to a winery?

DEAR READER, What a pleasure to be back! I admit it: these mailbags are now my favorite point of the week. Even during the contentious back-and-forth, I always enjoy opening my inbox to see words from you all. “Kind” ones, sometimes—but as you know from last week—I...

Our Sommeliers suggested wine

DEAR READER, I must be honest—I expected many more well wishes after posting that old journal entry. Everyone is modest when they say they don’t want well wishes, and so I expected there would be a few of you who saw through my “plea for privacy”. But, I forgive and I...

Because Life Needs Good and Evil

Black and white. Chaos and order. Sinner. Sinless. Life is a constant search for the happy medium, the yin and the yang. It’s as renowned psychologist Jordan B. Peterson explains, “Order is not enough. You can’t just be stable, and secure, and unchanging, because...

Thank you, Lehman Brothers?

On this day, 13 years ago, the world broke out in a panic when Lehman Brothers filed for Ch. 11 bankruptcy. Still the largest bankruptcy filing in US history, it was the climax of the Great Recession of 2007-2009. Subprime mortgages were to blame, lending money to...

Beer vs Wine, a timeless debate…

DEAR READER, Blah blah blah let’s get right to it! Dear Sommelier Ferdinand, You’ve dropped some hints that you look down on beer. Why is this, Sommelier Ferdinand? You have a growing fanbase—surely, you’re aware the effect that your insults have? And before you...

What would you do if you found an expensive wine in a cellar?

DEAR READER, Never in my life have I been happier to pontificate about wine than at my computer desk. In person is stimulating, sure, but they always talk back at some point. My lovely readers, however, only speak when I like! This internet thing has utility!...

The Beginning and The End.

Alas, the sun has crossed the celestial equator from north to south. Summer is now quite uneasy, shifting into fall in the north, while life is springing into action down south. What a beautiful time of the year! When grapes are cut from the vine to create new wine,...

Ever heard of a wine cocktail?

DEAR READER, I hope some of you learned from the reader letter last week [hyperlink to Week Ten post] and checked your attics! You never know how much wine sits above you, waiting to be uncorked and decanted—on someone else’s dime! Dear Sommelier Ferdinand, I have a...

The Future of Wine

We humans are bold if nothing else. Unlike any other species (that we know of), only we have chosen time and again to go boldly where no other has gone before. This holds especially true to the modern European, the first to really “discover” ignorance. Though they...

Could Mozart Make Your Wine More Complex?

We usually do three things when drinking wine: look at it, smell it and taste it. We activate three of our five senses to understand what’s going on in the glass. I propose we go further by incorporating sound and touch. Surely what we’re listening to while...

What on earth is a ‘Wine Decanter’?

DEAR READER, It’s come to my attention that many of you are ill-informed, misinformed, and frankly, uninformed about how wine is to be consumed. Were I only a wine enthusiast, it would be wholly dispiriting. But—wine is my profession, and I’m obligated to recognize...

“What’s My Next Question?” – Benjamin Kaplan

What’s My Next Question? On a random day like today 11 years ago, a legendary Harvard Law professor and lawyer, Benjamin Kaplan, died at 99 years of age. A rich, marked life that left an impact long after his last breathe. Apart from influencing the likes of Ruth...