When assets become liabilities, it is time to reshape the system in favor of citizens

by Jun 19, 2020Thinking outside the bottle0 comments


(Paulo Pinto

Alti Wine Exchange founding member)

Dear reader,

I’m happy to be back to you writing not only about fine wine investment, but also hopefully raising debates about the economy and the society as a whole.

A few months ago, we launched the idea of a Central Bank of Social Security (in a wine blog, what an irony) as a solution for the monetary system we have today. A system that is saturated with debt and is causing evident financial and economic problems.

The reason is simple: debt is a liability to all of us, but for the financial system it’s an asset. Therefore, our liabilities are their assets. Debt — there is too much of it: private debt, public debt, corporate debt. And all this debt is losing its ability to increase economic growth.

The saturation of debt is starting to cause cracks in the system. For instance, we learned that assets like oil can become liabilities when their price goes negative. Cash has become a liability too, given negative interest rates.

Abolishing the present system is the best solution to its problems.

So we started trying to answer only two questions:

1. Where we would want to go?

2. How to plan to get there?

Our thesis is the creation of a Central Bank of Social Security (CBSS) to replace national central banks. The goal to replace as much debt as possible by equity in order to put the necessary inflows of liquidity in the market and the system.

The CBSS will have two main responsibilities. The first one is to guarantee minimum basic income (as we have recently argued), and the second is to manage pension and social security (as explained here).

The rationale is because there is less risk entailed for the investor than it would have to when creating a private pension portfolio.

moneywine ed.jpg


Applying MMT (modern monetary theory) to the CBSS, they would guarantee the future responsibilities of pensions and social security.

A CBSS could create money and use the proceeds to guarantee minimum basic income and invest in equity investments with a value that rises and falls with the market, which would be held in individual Social Security Investment accounts.

The Bank of England, the European Central Bank and the Federal Reserve already own assets in excess of 25 percent of their countries’ GDPs, and this is done only to the benefit of banks and governments; So there is no reason not to invest those assets on behalf of the citizens.

The alternative to our suggested Central Bank of Social Security is raise taxes and cut benefits – which I see as a way to probably lead only to more societal dysfunction.

* * *

In the meantime, I will be sure to keep investing in fine and rare wines. As you may know by now, real, tangible assets are an excellent refuge for the pessimistic scenario ahead if debt and monetary inflation keep piling up. Fine wine is a valuable choice among these alternative investment class because it appreciates due to its rising quality and lessening supply.

You can read more about this in the articles on the gallery below.

Until then.


More articles by Paulo Pinto


Explore More from Our Blog

Maipo Valley Reds

DEAR READER, I am again-and-again charmed by my readers’ curiosity! It reminds me of being a young sommelier, ready to take on the world one glass at a time. I know far too much to feel that way again—but at least I can experience a shred of it through you all! Dear...

Liquid Harmony

Harmony. Think Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young. Think Picasso's The Old Guitarist. It’s that moment when various elements come together to create magic. And magic really is the word, no? Wine can also sip in harmony, and I can think of no better example than the...

Where Does the Phrase “Aging Like Fine Wine” Originate?

DEAR READER, I received this charming question from an inquisitive reader last week. Dear Sommelier Ferdinand, Where does the phrase “aging like fine wine” originate? It’s so fun! -Imani I just love your question! What a lively spirit you have, Imani! I’m more of a...


DEAR READER, Let’s get down to it! Dear Sommelier Ferdinand, I respect your point of view, but I must ask: don’t you think worshipping wines is partaking too mightily in the past? Wouldn’t you rather create your own memories than indulge in nostalgia? -Ethan Ethan,...

The Top 10 Wines to Invest In Today

Imagine that back in the day you invested in a case of 1992 Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon wine. When released, mailing list members had the chance to snag a bottle of this "cult wine" for a mere US$75.00. Fast forward to now, and one bottle alone goes for...

We buy wine with the intention of making money over periods of time.

We buy wine with the intention of making money over periods of time. Rethinking retirement is a famous book of John Piper with the goal to challenge people to have a far greater purpose in life. Rethinking retirement is also an absolute must for Pension funds, because...


DEAR READER, Sometimes you all make me so proud with your questions. Yes! —even I, the one and only Sommelier Ferdinand, can learn from you keyboard clackers. Here is such a question I received over the last week: Dear Sommelier Ferdinand, I live in Los Angeles, and...

Welcome, Lady Adelaide

Alas! The Quinta Do Vallado Adelaide 2015 is now available! Though my posts generally focus on a historical event related to the wine I’m writing about, today’s is all about NOW! There’s no time to look back because our latest IBO, an ultra-premium Douro Valley...

Sommelier Ferdinand on Wine Schedules…

Let’s jump straight to the grape, shall we? I found this letter particularly interesting: Dear Sommelier Ferdinand, "I think what you’re doing is good, explaining wine and wine drinking to newbies like me. I found this on the internet last week and was wondering if...

Thanks for the “New World,” Magellan!

When it comes to wine, oceanic influences are quite significant. Yet what happens in Casablanca, Chile is far different from Bordeaux, France.   Sure, all oceans and seas are massive moderators, but think about coastal France, Portugal and Spain in comparison to...

Grapes are of the Essence

Every morning we wake up at a certain time on a certain day and we go about our routines. You probably have multiple clocks, from one hanging on the wall to your stove, your phone and on your wrist. But it hasn’t always been this way. For the majority of human...

Would you bring your child to a winery?

DEAR READER, What a pleasure to be back! I admit it: these mailbags are now my favorite point of the week. Even during the contentious back-and-forth, I always enjoy opening my inbox to see words from you all. “Kind” ones, sometimes—but as you know from last week—I...