Why (and how) social security could save capitalism

by Apr 3, 2020Thinking outside the bottle0 comments

Making each taxpayer effectively a shareholder might just be the way to reset the system.

Making each taxpayer effectively a shareholder might just be the way to reset the system.

Dear readers,

I’m Breno, back here with some thoughts on the economic unfolding of the coronavirus crisis. After all, that’s an issue which every one of us, investors, are extremely anxious about.


(Click here to see our full list of available wines to buy now)

Yesterday, as I was asking our Instagram followers what kind of wine they were planning to drink this weekend, an old friend of mine suggested a Brunello di Montalcino. Great option. He subscribed to the IBO of IoSonoDonatella, the beautiful Brunello by the first Italian all-woman winery – but decided to take delivery of some of the bottles subscribed. I don’t think he is going to be much of an investor, as he claimed he wants to be, if he keeps drinking it.

Oh: and just yesterday I bought my first IBO, a German gem launched this week. Just the first of many bottles, I hope. It’s selling fast!


A few days ago, I mentioned Yuval Harari’s article and how worried he is about the social experiment we are living. Just a day later, I read that former UK Prime Minister Gordon Brown was calling for a kind of Global Government to fight covid-19. Honestly, it sounded a bit out of touch, given the highly competitive geopolitical reality of these days and the extreme difficulties we would have on developing such a taskforce to tackle the social issues of the pandemic.

Personally, it seems to me the economic focus should be on rethinking social security and the welfare state.

I’ve had some very interesting debates with our founding member Paulo Pinto on this, and then decided to write this article on it.

Paulo’s main stance is to replace the current central banks with Central Banks of Social Security, to guarantee that money goes bottom-up, instead of up-down – as it has been done so far.

The global financial crisis due to the pandemic has been here for over a month already, and the extreme remedies – applied through massive government and Central Banks intervention – will have probably no results in view of the truly gigantic disaster in the job market. This week’s news on the unforeseen boom in unemployment claims in the United States shows that.

The consequences will probably be the biggest wave of delinquencies in history. If debt cannot be repaid, the solution known is called restructuring of the debt. Complicated, right?

A new model is needed to guarantee not only the valuation of assets, but also the future responsibilities of reforms and social security.

I find the idea of Central Banks of Social Security quite interesting, and even though I would have never thought it would be possible before the current crisis, this idea seems to be ever wiser and not that hard to implement.

This new concept of central banks, instead of the current model, would guarantee pensions and minimum income to people. Banks would need to go back and operate under 100% reserve model and compete for clients by offering true market rates, instead of gambling on bonds and housing markets without liquidity – and having to be rescued when a crisis comes.


Nowadays, as banks and big companies are saved through giant rescue packages, people who have been contributing to social security for their whole lives lack protection and deeply suffer, not knowing what will come next. That’s precisely what has happened so far in this crisis.

For example, only very recently governments have started to urgently adopt more severe measures to provide urgent income for the people and smaller companies, whilst the big players have been contemplated by multibillionaire plans. Too big to fail.

I then asked him: “Paulo, but how can you convince players in the capitalist system to accept such a move that seems to turn away from what capitalism itself has become decades ago?”

He simply put it that way:

This social state model based on a Central Bank of Social Security aims to make capitalism truly capitalist by making each taxpayer a shareholder.”

Well, he got me with that one. Kudos.


There’s not going to be a lasting solution for this frenzy of printing money without investing in the bottom of the pyramid: the people directly in order to guarantee dignity. This is the only way to go back to basics and reset the system. Central banks are nationalizing the economy, and we need to free the people in order to free the economy.

Central banks, and particularly the FED, have a reason now with the pandemic crisis to print as much money as needed by the banks. This is only the first part of the problem. The second part is when the world loses confidence in their currencies and particularly in the US dollar as a store of value, but this we will keep it for another day.

Have a nice weekend!

Featured reads by Paulo Pinto

Explore More from Our Blog

Would you bring your child to a winery?

DEAR READER, What a pleasure to be back! I admit it: these mailbags are now my favorite point of the week. Even during the contentious back-and-forth, I always enjoy opening my inbox to see words from you all. “Kind” ones, sometimes—but as you know from last week—I...

Our Sommeliers suggested wine

DEAR READER, I must be honest—I expected many more well wishes after posting that old journal entry. Everyone is modest when they say they don’t want well wishes, and so I expected there would be a few of you who saw through my “plea for privacy”. But, I forgive and I...

Because Life Needs Good and Evil

Black and white. Chaos and order. Sinner. Sinless. Life is a constant search for the happy medium, the yin and the yang. It’s as renowned psychologist Jordan B. Peterson explains, “Order is not enough. You can’t just be stable, and secure, and unchanging, because...

Thank you, Lehman Brothers?

On this day, 13 years ago, the world broke out in a panic when Lehman Brothers filed for Ch. 11 bankruptcy. Still the largest bankruptcy filing in US history, it was the climax of the Great Recession of 2007-2009. Subprime mortgages were to blame, lending money to...

Beer vs Wine, a timeless debate…

DEAR READER, Blah blah blah let’s get right to it! Dear Sommelier Ferdinand, You’ve dropped some hints that you look down on beer. Why is this, Sommelier Ferdinand? You have a growing fanbase—surely, you’re aware the effect that your insults have? And before you...

What would you do if you found an expensive wine in a cellar?

DEAR READER, Never in my life have I been happier to pontificate about wine than at my computer desk. In person is stimulating, sure, but they always talk back at some point. My lovely readers, however, only speak when I like! This internet thing has utility!...

The Beginning and The End.

Alas, the sun has crossed the celestial equator from north to south. Summer is now quite uneasy, shifting into fall in the north, while life is springing into action down south. What a beautiful time of the year! When grapes are cut from the vine to create new wine,...

Ever heard of a wine cocktail?

DEAR READER, I hope some of you learned from the reader letter last week [hyperlink to Week Ten post] and checked your attics! You never know how much wine sits above you, waiting to be uncorked and decanted—on someone else’s dime! Dear Sommelier Ferdinand, I have a...

The Future of Wine

We humans are bold if nothing else. Unlike any other species (that we know of), only we have chosen time and again to go boldly where no other has gone before. This holds especially true to the modern European, the first to really “discover” ignorance. Though they...

Could Mozart Make Your Wine More Complex?

We usually do three things when drinking wine: look at it, smell it and taste it. We activate three of our five senses to understand what’s going on in the glass. I propose we go further by incorporating sound and touch. Surely what we’re listening to while...

What on earth is a ‘Wine Decanter’?

DEAR READER, It’s come to my attention that many of you are ill-informed, misinformed, and frankly, uninformed about how wine is to be consumed. Were I only a wine enthusiast, it would be wholly dispiriting. But—wine is my profession, and I’m obligated to recognize...

“What’s My Next Question?” – Benjamin Kaplan

What’s My Next Question? On a random day like today 11 years ago, a legendary Harvard Law professor and lawyer, Benjamin Kaplan, died at 99 years of age. A rich, marked life that left an impact long after his last breathe. Apart from influencing the likes of Ruth...