What makes Old World and New World wines different?

by Jun 24, 2020News0 comments

The Californian highlights of the iconic 1976 Judgment of Paris, that held US wines as real contenders to French vintages (photo credit: Museum of American History - Smithsonian Institution)The Californian highlights of the iconic 1976 Judgment of Paris, that held US wines as real contenders to French vintages (photo credit: Museum of American History - Smithsonian Institution)

The Californian highlights of the iconic 1976 Judgment of Paris, that held US wines as real contenders to French vintages (photo credit: Museum of American History – Smithsonian Institution)

Hi, dear reader,

I’m Breno, back with wine history and some debates to motivate your fine wine week, no matter if you’re still on quarantine or are finally able to enjoy a little bit more on the outside.

Personally, I’ve been enjoying the sunny early summer weather in Lisbon and going to the beach while I think of my next moves. Safe visits to wineries in Italy back on track? Who knows? Staying safe is the priority, but thankfully a sense of (new) normality seems to be showing up.

* * *

I’ve been meaning to address an interesting topic for a while: Old World, New World. What’s that all about? What makes wines from these two “worlds” different? Are there any best wines for investment when comparing both?

The Old World vs. the New World of wine, explained

Sports metaphor: have you ever watched a friendly match in football, basketball or tennis like “Brazil vs. Rest of world XI”? Those matches usually destined to fundraising?

Well, here we have something that many would call “Europe vs. Rest of the world”. But things are not exactly like this: other regions around the Mediterranean carry a gigantic share of winemaking history (such as North Africa and the Near East). Thanks, Phoenicians!

Heading into practical terms, here’s what you need to know about the Old World and the New World in wine.

READ ALSO: Opus One, the Californian winemaking jewel that merged the Old and the New World

2020 alti fine wine investment report banner.jpg2020 alti fine wine investment report banner.jpg

 

Old World: region and tradition-centered wines

The Old World congregates the birthplaces of wine. From European countries to the Mediterranean basin, one could argue that everything spanning France to Spain to Italy to Germany to Portugal to Austria to Greece to Lebanon to Israel to Croatia to Georgia to Romania to Hungary and Switzerland and more (whew!) could feature in this category.

In very generalistic terms – which do not always apply, since wines from its different countries greatly vary even domestically due to grapes, climate, methods, soil –, Old World wines tend to be lighter-bodied, higher in acidity and lower in alcohol, something usually associated with cooler climates. That comes only regarding general characteristics on its wines, and is many times inaccurate.

Terroir is a major factor here. At the same time, different vintages can show very different results when climatic factors interfere, for examples. Steadiness in modern winemaking techniques, apart from climatic factors, is something you’ll find more in South American wines (from the New World that you’ll read right after).

julien burgundy grand crus 3.jpgjulien burgundy grand crus 3.jpg

However, the big thing I see about the Old World, as one could expect to generalize, is the great focus on tradition. The wines from its countries are well known for having a pretty restrictive production, following specific guidelines in accordance with rules that govern the labeling in their regions.

Think of labels: here you’ll find lesser focus on the grapes and more on the origins of the wine. Name, producer, geographical indication (most likely region first, and eventually country). This information is proudly kept as generations go by, highlighting the history behind the winemaking and the bottle itself.

Think of great Bordeaux, Chianti, Rioja, Douro like the ones we offer, for example: you know how good these geographically-oriented wines are, but can you say by heart what grapes compose each? Maybe not at first…

A good example are the interesting specifics you see in French wine, like our Chief Wine Officer Julien Miquel has been exploring lately.

Yes: heritage is how one can define the Old World in very general terms, especially if you think mainstream European wine regions.

New World: migration and winemaking experiments

Instead, when we think of a New World, it could even recall the idea of a New World put forward centuries ago by Vespucci: the new lands, outside the Euro-African realm. In historiographical approaches, this is quite controversial, but that’s another debate!

But here we are not talking only about the American continent: in winemaking, the New World means everything outside the Old World. It includes various countries with vastly different winemaking traditions, such as the United States, Argentina, Chile, Australia, New Zealand, South Africa – and even China, which has strongly rooted traditions that few from the outside know.

All in all, this vast category comprises more of a “migrant” approach in wine: less emphasis on century-old traditions and denominations, with some borrowing and exploring more freely on modern techniques and technology (with many winemakers resting their wines in stainless steel tanks other than oak, for instance), practices, blends – experimentation, should I call it that way.

Also, it is commonly pointed out that New World wines tend to be heavier-bodied, less acidic and substantially fruitier, apart from the minerality you’ll find in some Old-Worlds. A perfect example? The highly prized Montes Folly, the ultra-premium Chilean Syrah we have.

Montes vineyards in Apalta, ChileMontes vineyards in Apalta, Chile

Montes vineyards in Apalta, Chile

There are many who claim the New World wines almost necessarily come from warmer climates, and that this is a preponderant factor in these characteristics. Maybe Argentinians and Chileans from colder regions, and also Mediterranean basin (Old World!) winemakers, will disagree with this generalization. Up for debate!

And, unlike the Old World wines, you won’t find New World labels based on their geographical indication: they will show you upfront the grapes or blends that compose the wine, in a much lesser region-oriented fashion.

However, a curious factor is that, in a globalized world, the winemaking lines are pretty blurred: you’ll find many characteristics of Old World wines in the New World, with (for example) Argentina and Chile picking the best from French grapes and giving deep and interesting approaches to respectively Malbec and Carmenère.

Also, many California wines resemble specific Italian red wines – whilst some Italian regions make savory and fruity vintages.

No dogmas, okay?

More featured stories


Five useful apps for wine lovers anywhere in the world

It is easy to have quick options to manage your cellar; acquaint with oenophiles; compare prices and vintages; develop tasting profiles; meet new wine styles; buy bottles and find pairings.


What's ahead for French 2021 vintages after the frosts?

Catastrophic freezing affected vineyards in most of France, with nearly lost harvests adding up to the pandemic and tariffs that producers already face


Not all the same: a quick guide to rosé and its different styles

 


Wines that smell like spring: floral aromas to try this season

 


Remembering Steven Spurrier, the gentleman who globalized the love of fine wine

 


A celebration of the women who inspire and shape the wine world

 


Unearthing and mapping the unique heritage of Portuguese wine and its hidden gems

 


Five common myths in terms of tasting wine

 


A virtual trip to Tuscany and its greatest wines - from classics to Super Tuscans to whites

 


Carménère and other grapes saved from extinction to produce world-class wines

 

Is there anything such as a ‘better wine world’?

No, there surely isn’t. And no rules should be really “enforced” in this sense. Open yourself to new experiences!

Remember the 1976 landmark Judgment of Paris, which sanctified Californian wine? Blind taste, buy different, explore.

There are excellent variations in grapes such as Syrah/Shiraz going on between the Old and the New worlds, for example, as senior financial advisor Sergey Glekov has put it recently.

If one claims Old World wines are necessarily better, ask them why. It could be that they are more focused on sipping history than in opening themselves to new experiences in (very interesting) wines.

“OKAY. SO WHAT HAVE YOU GOT to offer?”

Thought we would have forgotten our own partners in the Old and the New worlds of wine? Wrong. Check out our Old-New World partnerships launched by Alti Wine Exchange:

Featured


The Lafite Spirit: our Wine Club offers from Domaines Barons de Rothschild (Lafite)

The Alti Wine Club is thrilled to offer exclusive releases by a global symbol of winemaking tradition and excellence that goes so much beyond Bordeaux


Opus One, the Californian winemaking jewel that merged the Old and the New World

When Rothschild and Mondavi came together, marvelous Bordeaux-style blends ensued. Meet the Napa Valley winery and its outstanding wines Alti Wine Club is offering

And these are the wines listed on our exchange and marketplace (as of April 2021).

See you next time!

Featured


Five useful apps for wine lovers anywhere in the world


Alti Wine Exchange Indexes in 2020: despite it all, safe and strong returns for fine wine


Five common myths in terms of tasting wine


Read and watch our fine wine investment tips and analyses


Introducing our internal index for fine wine investors


Why people are turning their passion for wine into investment

 


How to build wealth with a strategy based on fine wine

 


How to ensure safety when investing in fine wine

 


Wine glossary: our quick dictionary of essential words for every wine lover

 


Five things you need to know to invest in fine wine

 

Explore More from Our Blog

Would you bring your child to a winery?

DEAR READER, What a pleasure to be back! I admit it: these mailbags are now my favorite point of the week. Even during the contentious back-and-forth, I always enjoy opening my inbox to see words from you all. “Kind” ones, sometimes—but as you know from last week—I...

Our Sommeliers suggested wine

DEAR READER, I must be honest—I expected many more well wishes after posting that old journal entry. Everyone is modest when they say they don’t want well wishes, and so I expected there would be a few of you who saw through my “plea for privacy”. But, I forgive and I...

Because Life Needs Good and Evil

Black and white. Chaos and order. Sinner. Sinless. Life is a constant search for the happy medium, the yin and the yang. It’s as renowned psychologist Jordan B. Peterson explains, “Order is not enough. You can’t just be stable, and secure, and unchanging, because...

Thank you, Lehman Brothers?

On this day, 13 years ago, the world broke out in a panic when Lehman Brothers filed for Ch. 11 bankruptcy. Still the largest bankruptcy filing in US history, it was the climax of the Great Recession of 2007-2009. Subprime mortgages were to blame, lending money to...

Beer vs Wine, a timeless debate…

DEAR READER, Blah blah blah let’s get right to it! Dear Sommelier Ferdinand, You’ve dropped some hints that you look down on beer. Why is this, Sommelier Ferdinand? You have a growing fanbase—surely, you’re aware the effect that your insults have? And before you...

What would you do if you found an expensive wine in a cellar?

DEAR READER, Never in my life have I been happier to pontificate about wine than at my computer desk. In person is stimulating, sure, but they always talk back at some point. My lovely readers, however, only speak when I like! This internet thing has utility!...

The Beginning and The End.

Alas, the sun has crossed the celestial equator from north to south. Summer is now quite uneasy, shifting into fall in the north, while life is springing into action down south. What a beautiful time of the year! When grapes are cut from the vine to create new wine,...

Ever heard of a wine cocktail?

DEAR READER, I hope some of you learned from the reader letter last week [hyperlink to Week Ten post] and checked your attics! You never know how much wine sits above you, waiting to be uncorked and decanted—on someone else’s dime! Dear Sommelier Ferdinand, I have a...

The Future of Wine

We humans are bold if nothing else. Unlike any other species (that we know of), only we have chosen time and again to go boldly where no other has gone before. This holds especially true to the modern European, the first to really “discover” ignorance. Though they...

Could Mozart Make Your Wine More Complex?

We usually do three things when drinking wine: look at it, smell it and taste it. We activate three of our five senses to understand what’s going on in the glass. I propose we go further by incorporating sound and touch. Surely what we’re listening to while...

What on earth is a ‘Wine Decanter’?

DEAR READER, It’s come to my attention that many of you are ill-informed, misinformed, and frankly, uninformed about how wine is to be consumed. Were I only a wine enthusiast, it would be wholly dispiriting. But—wine is my profession, and I’m obligated to recognize...

“What’s My Next Question?” – Benjamin Kaplan

What’s My Next Question? On a random day like today 11 years ago, a legendary Harvard Law professor and lawyer, Benjamin Kaplan, died at 99 years of age. A rich, marked life that left an impact long after his last breathe. Apart from influencing the likes of Ruth...