The ‘Sour Grapes’ great wine fraud – and how to guarantee scam-free wine investment

by Apr 24, 2020News, Wine Trading Academy0 comments

The (in)famous wine trickster Rudy Kurniawan (photo by Mel Hill, 2002)The (in)famous wine trickster Rudy Kurniawan (photo by Mel Hill, 2002)

 

The (in)famous wine trickster Rudy Kurniawan (photo by Mel Hill, 2002)

Hey, everyone,

I’m Breno, once again trying to entertain you as much as possible with all things fine wine and wine investment during quarantine!

Here in Portugal, where I’ve been since before this all began, things are slowly seeming that will become better. Of course, the state of emergency is still ongoing (and should keep like that for a while!) and social distancing will be the new reality for a long time.

I had planned some work trips to Italy, as I’ve mentioned a few times before. But now things are looking better in Lisbon. While I make my plans for the medium and long term, I’m thinking of staying here longer until things have cleared up!

I might as well think of new tours to wineries like our partners José Maria da Fonseca and Quinta do Vallado

Moving on…

Some of you may recall that I referred a few weeks ago to some nice films and series about wine. Hope they have inspired you!

Today, I want to go back to a part of that post and talk about one specific documentary featured there – and which should interest those who, like me, invest in wine:

Sour Grapes.

(You can find it on Netflix, and it’s really worth it).

This is not a mere wine story: it’s a tale of deception and forgery. The documentary follows the story of wine fraudster Rudy Kurniawan and the famous victims he made in the process.

In the early 2000s, Kurniawan started buying rare vintages at wine auctions in Los Angeles, gaining fame as an alleged heir of a wealthy Sino-Indonesian family who had a fine eye (and taste) to identify outstanding fine wines to buy and sell them later on.

As time went by, Kurniawan became famous in the local wine scene for his exquisite palate, forging friendships with fellow tasters and amassing high amounts for wines he was putting up for auctions. At one point, he was making millions out of fine wines in each auction for his own bottles.

The problem all along is that the wines he was making so much money out of had been counterfeit. Kurniawan had defrauded auction houses and investors by using cheaper wines into original bottles or altering bottles to enhance their value.

His scamming practices were only discovered when defrauded billionaire Bill Koch and other investors started noticing discrepancies and the FBI got involved, raiding his house and finding Kurniawan’s counterfeiting equipment.

He was then arrested, went to trial and was sentenced to 10 years in jail. In November 2020, however, he was released and handed over to the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement in El Paso, Texas, where he was being held until officially deported in early April 2021.

To this day, it’s still unclear whether he had overseas help for the forgery or not (I believe he did, but that’s another debate).

Some counterfeit bottles and the equipment found by the FBI in Kurniawan’s house in CaliforniaSome counterfeit bottles and the equipment found by the FBI in Kurniawan’s house in California

Some counterfeit bottles and the equipment found by the FBI in Kurniawan’s house in California

***

Interesting story, isn’t it?

I should stress that this is a film that refers to a problem that mostly happened to very wealthy investors and collectors. However, scams are something wine investors should be aware of. For instance:

  • Cold callers selling regular wines claiming they are top-of-the-crop and age-worthy vintages.

  • So-called ‘joint exclusive offers for rare vintages to buy only this weekend’ that arrive in your email box from unknown websites.

  • Auctions of relatively unknown wines for high prices.

  • Poorly stored wines sold as if they had been properly preserved.

The traditional investor may feel anxious about buying fine wine in auctions or through the internet. Unfortunately, the abovementioned problems have proven to be perils in this business, and it’s quite challenging to tackle these problems given the lack of regulation in the market.

Enter Alti Wine Exchange.

We unite simplicity and the maximum transparency in wine investment to provide investors with the best possible vintages with less concerns about being misled. This is how – quick and simple:

  • For both our initial bottle offerings (IBOs) and Wine Club offers, by working directly with producers, we provide full disclosure about the wines, their stock and its allocation for Alti Wine Exchange.

  • We provide the value of any given wine available at any time on marketplace, preventing mis-selling from cold callers. More importantly, each of these wines already has a retail market price for reference in the consumer market.

  • We also provide full verifiable control over supply chain – including handling for the product being acquired for the fund or the portfolio.

  • Our trades are done with blockchain technology, which guarantees ownership of the wines as digital tokens. One should buy the token associated with the wine to become its owner. 1 token = 1 bottle, without even needing to reclaim the bottle in order to have it safely stored under his/her name. And although blockchain is frequently associated with cryptocurrencies, we do not accept nor trade with them.

  • The wines listed on our platform are sent from producers to a bonded warehouse (the Bordeaux City Bond), being stored in the best possible conditions, under minimum maintenance costs (that are presented and explained to all investors). You only pay the applicable VAT and customs fees if you decide to redeem your bottles for private possession.

We never meant our work to be that complex. And, well, are working to implement this better day by day.

Any other doubts? Check our FAQ!

_____

(Read also: Ten fun facts about wine you (possibly) didn’t know)

Featured


Summer is coming – and things really do not look promising

Building a sound strategy for your resources in the face of inflation and worsening living standards has become more crucial than ever


Five useful apps for wine lovers anywhere in the world

 


What's ahead for French 2021 vintages after the frosts?

 


The Lafite Spirit: our Wine Club offers from Domaines Barons de Rothschild (Lafite)

 


Investing in fine wine remotely in times of Covid, tariffs and stuck cargo ships

 


Outside the bottle | Building wealth wisely, change is both need and opportunity

 


Not all the same: a quick guide to rosé and its different styles

 


Wines that smell like spring: floral aromas to try this season

 


Remembering Steven Spurrier, the gentleman who globalized the love of fine wine

 


A celebration of the women who inspire and shape the wine world

 

Explore More from Our Blog

Would you bring your child to a winery?

DEAR READER, What a pleasure to be back! I admit it: these mailbags are now my favorite point of the week. Even during the contentious back-and-forth, I always enjoy opening my inbox to see words from you all. “Kind” ones, sometimes—but as you know from last week—I...

Our Sommeliers suggested wine

DEAR READER, I must be honest—I expected many more well wishes after posting that old journal entry. Everyone is modest when they say they don’t want well wishes, and so I expected there would be a few of you who saw through my “plea for privacy”. But, I forgive and I...

Because Life Needs Good and Evil

Black and white. Chaos and order. Sinner. Sinless. Life is a constant search for the happy medium, the yin and the yang. It’s as renowned psychologist Jordan B. Peterson explains, “Order is not enough. You can’t just be stable, and secure, and unchanging, because...

Thank you, Lehman Brothers?

On this day, 13 years ago, the world broke out in a panic when Lehman Brothers filed for Ch. 11 bankruptcy. Still the largest bankruptcy filing in US history, it was the climax of the Great Recession of 2007-2009. Subprime mortgages were to blame, lending money to...

Beer vs Wine, a timeless debate…

DEAR READER, Blah blah blah let’s get right to it! Dear Sommelier Ferdinand, You’ve dropped some hints that you look down on beer. Why is this, Sommelier Ferdinand? You have a growing fanbase—surely, you’re aware the effect that your insults have? And before you...

What would you do if you found an expensive wine in a cellar?

DEAR READER, Never in my life have I been happier to pontificate about wine than at my computer desk. In person is stimulating, sure, but they always talk back at some point. My lovely readers, however, only speak when I like! This internet thing has utility!...

The Beginning and The End.

Alas, the sun has crossed the celestial equator from north to south. Summer is now quite uneasy, shifting into fall in the north, while life is springing into action down south. What a beautiful time of the year! When grapes are cut from the vine to create new wine,...

Ever heard of a wine cocktail?

DEAR READER, I hope some of you learned from the reader letter last week [hyperlink to Week Ten post] and checked your attics! You never know how much wine sits above you, waiting to be uncorked and decanted—on someone else’s dime! Dear Sommelier Ferdinand, I have a...

The Future of Wine

We humans are bold if nothing else. Unlike any other species (that we know of), only we have chosen time and again to go boldly where no other has gone before. This holds especially true to the modern European, the first to really “discover” ignorance. Though they...

Could Mozart Make Your Wine More Complex?

We usually do three things when drinking wine: look at it, smell it and taste it. We activate three of our five senses to understand what’s going on in the glass. I propose we go further by incorporating sound and touch. Surely what we’re listening to while...

What on earth is a ‘Wine Decanter’?

DEAR READER, It’s come to my attention that many of you are ill-informed, misinformed, and frankly, uninformed about how wine is to be consumed. Were I only a wine enthusiast, it would be wholly dispiriting. But—wine is my profession, and I’m obligated to recognize...

“What’s My Next Question?” – Benjamin Kaplan

What’s My Next Question? On a random day like today 11 years ago, a legendary Harvard Law professor and lawyer, Benjamin Kaplan, died at 99 years of age. A rich, marked life that left an impact long after his last breathe. Apart from influencing the likes of Ruth...